Peloton Bike Shoes Review

THIS POST MAY CONTAIN AFFILIATE LINKS, MEANING I MAY RECEIVE A SMALL COMPENSATION IF YOU CLICK ON ONE OF THEM. THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO COST TO YOU FOR CLICKING ON THESE LINKS. FOR MORE INFORMATION, PLEASE SEE MY PRIVACY AND DISCLOSURE PAGE.


peloton bike shoes

What are the best Peloton bike shoes? What spin shoes are compatible with a Peloton cycle? How do the Peloton bike shoes fit?

These are some of the most common questions I get about Peloton bike ownership. It seems that buying Peloton bike shoes is where most people get tripped up. And I get it.

Before I got my Peloton bike shoes, I wore regular sneakers to ride a regular bike. I did have toe cages or shoe cages on my pedals. But I’d never ridden a road bike with clip-in bike shoes.

That all changed when we got our Peloton bike in 2016. At that time the bike came with a free pair of shoes. Both my husband and I have very wide feet. Some might say his feet are harder to fit because of his exceptionally high arch.

So when it came time to choose the Peloton bike shoes that would come with the cycle, we went with a pair for him. I’ll discuss a little later where I found Peloton spin shoes for sale that I ended up buying. Therefore, if you’re looking for cycling shoes for wide feet–whether your have a Peloton or not–I think you’ll want to read on.

Also, scroll down to access my Amazon shopping list for Peloton bike shoes.

Peloton shoes sizing

When it comes to Peloton shoe sizing, I’m going to talk first about the Peloton brand bike shoes that you can get with your bike. Then, I’ll address other brands of spin or cycling shoes that are compatible with the Peloton bike.

Do you need special shoes for Peloton

When I say Peloton compatible shoes, what I really mean is this: the cleat or clip that goes on the bottom of the shoe is compatible with the Peloton pedal. The pedals take a Look Delta cleat, which is a red triangle (thus the Delta).

So do you need special shoes for Peloton? Well, if you want to be able to clip in while you ride, then yes. And make sure you get shoes that take cleats that are compatible with the Peloton pedals.

bottom of peloton bike shoes
This is what the Look Delta cleats look like and what you want on the bottom of your Peloton bike shoes.

Peloton spin shoes sizing guide

Like I said when we got our Peloton bike, it came with a free pair of shoes. My husband took the free pair of shoes. As far as the Peloton bike shoe sizing, here’s what I can tell you. In real life my husband wears a size 13EEE shoe. Those are some wide feet. So when it came time to choose the bike shoes for Peloton, he went with a size 47.

First, I should say that the European sizing confused him. He had no idea how to translate a size 13 into a size in the 40s. “What size Peloton shoes should I get?” I remember him asking me.

Then, while the Peloton website doesn’t have a shoe size chart or a shoe sizing guide, per se, it does offer size “translations” right in the cart. So, he was able to see that a 47 was a men’s size 13.

Peloton bike shoes for men

Here’s what you need to know if you decide you want to buy the Peloton brand cycling shoes for men. First, the Peloton men’s bike shoes do not come in every size. Next, there are only two sizes that are equivalent to a half size. They would be men’s size 10.5 and men’s size 13.5.

So what sizes do they come in? Here are the Peloton bike shoes sizing options for men. Think of it as your Peloton shoe size chart. 

  • 40 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 7)
  • 41 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 8)
  • 42 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 9)
  • 43 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 10)
  • 44 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 10.5)
  • 45 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 11)
  • 46 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 12)
  • 47 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 13)
  • 48 (which is the equivalent of men’s size 13.5)

The men’s shoe sizing options are from American size 7 to 13.5. I would think that this range would likely fit most men’s feet. However, if you’re looking for Peloton bike shoes for a boy, you might want to look at the women’s size. I’ve listed them below. If you wear larger than a 13.5, I’ll have some non-Peloton bike shoe options for you later in this blog post.

Peloton bike shoes for women

Like the Peloton bike shoes for men, the shoe sizes for women don’t cover every size. However, the range is pretty big.

The women’s Peloton cycling shoes go from women’s size 5 to women’s size 12. That’s impressive. On the other hand, unlike the men’s shoes, there are no half-size options.

Here are the Peloton bike shoes sizing options for women. Again, think of this as your Peloton shoe size chart. 

  • 36 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 5)
  • 37 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 6)
  • 38 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 7)
  • 39 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 8)
  • 40 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 9)
  • 41 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 10)
  • 42 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 11)
  • 43 (which is the equivalent of women’s size 12)

Where to buy Peloton bike shoes

Of course, you can buy your Peloton bike shoes from Peloton itself. You can always splurge for the accessories package, which includes shoes. That’s what my daughter did when she bought her Peloton.

However, there are two places I’ve discovered online where you can buy Peloton brand shoes. One is eBay. There are tons of Peloton shoes for sale on eBay, which you can check out using this link.

Two, try Poshmark. Poshmark is the online selling platform that I’ve used to make money consigning my clothing. One Poshmark you can find gently used as well as new in box (NIB) or new with tags (NWT) Peloton bike shoes.

If you’ve never used Poshmark before, you can sign up using my link. Plug in the code SUDDENLYFRUGAL to save $10 off your first Poshmark purchase.

Peloton shoe size chart

Since Peloton doesn’t have a shoe size chart, I made one with the information I had on hand. This should be super helpful for you as you shop for your Peloton shoes.

You can also grab a free printable of this Peloton shoe size chart on my Printables page. It will download in PDF, which will make it easy for you to print out.

Note: this chart is for the Peloton brand of cycling shoes only. If you decide to buy another brand, please refer to the sizing chart from that manufacturer. 

peloton shoe size chart

Women to kids size shoes

I know there are a lot of petite people who ride Pelotons. It’s one of the reasons there is a “Shortie Tribe” on the bike as well as a Facebook group. And as a shortie myself from a shortie family, I know that short people often have small feet.

In addition, I know there are many Peloton users who have Peloton kids. It’s one of the reasons that I wrote my post on Peloton for kids.

One of the most common–if not the most common question people ask about Peloton and kids–is this: where can I find Peloton shoes for my children?

Converting shoes sizes

Well, with both communities in mind, I did some research on shoe sizes. And it turns out that converting youth shoe sizes or big kid shoe sizes to women’s sizes is not that hard.

Basically, you subtract two from the women’s size to get the youth size or the big kids shoe size. To make your life easier, I’ve created the womens to kids size shoes chart below. You can also print out a PDF copy of it on my Printable pages for free. 

And fun fact, shortie tribe: youth size shoes are often cheaper than adult shoes for everyday shoes. So, if you have smaller women’s feet, you might want to shop in the youth section to save money.

peloton shoe size chart kids to womens

Kids Peloton bike shoes 

This is good information if you’re looking for kids cycling shoes for Peloton. Knowing that these go as low as women’s size 5 means you can think of them in youth sizes.

The calculus for converting women’s size to youth sizes is roughly this: subtract 1.5 to 2 sizes. So for a women’s size 5, you would size down to a youth size 3 or 3.5.

Here is my blog post about Peloton for kids, including information on kids’ cycle shoes for Peloton.

Peloton shoes sizing for men and women

When buying the shoes, if you’re selecting from 40 up, you’ll see the sizes represented for women and men. Also, the Peloton bike shoes cost $125, regardless of what size you’re getting.

I guess that’s a good thing that they don’t discriminate based on gender or foot size with prices. However, you can do much better than $125 for spin or cycling shoes. I’ll address that a little later in this article.

If you’re looking to convert Euro shoe sizes to women’s US sizes, this chart should help.

peloton shoe size chart euro sizes

How do the Peloton shoes fit

As I’ve mentioned Bill has wide feet. The Peloton bike shoes do not come in varying widths. So he was worried that he would not fit his extra wide feet with high arches.

So, do Peloton shoes fit wide feet? Well, guess what? The shoes fit perfectly. They were a little snug around the front. But the two Velcro straps across the top allowed for his high arch. And the ratchet strap also allowed enough room for the shoes to be snug but not too tight.

If you wear a half size, I would recommend sizing up. Some people have reported that the Peloton spin shoes run small. Others, like my husband, feel like they fit true to size. Then again, he’s a size 13 and he was able to get a size 43 in Peloton spin shoes. So I’ll say it again. If you wear a half size, it’s probably better to size up in the Peloton bike shoes.

How often should I replace my cycling shoes

I have to be honest: this wasn’t a question I had even considered until almost four years of riding my Peloton bike. The Bontrager shoes served me well on my nearly 1,100 rides. Until one day they didn’t.

Why? Because I started to notice that my feet were aching after every ride. It didn’t matter how long I rode. The sides of my feet hurt afterwards. I checked to make sure my cleats hadn’t move–they hadn’t–because that can sometimes be why your feet hurt after riding your Peloton. 

What other Peloton riders told me

So I took my question to my fellow Peloton riders: how often should I replace my cycling shoes? And guess what? I was years beyond when I should have gotten new shoes. Every person who replied to my query said they replaced their shoes every year without fail. Those that sweat a lot or might be riding longer distances would replace their shoes more often.

The fact that my shoes were starting to fall apart should have been a hint that I needed new ones. The Velcro straps were pretty much falling apart every time I undid them. So, today I ordered new shoes. Actually, I ordered two.

You can buy Bontrager brand of cycling shoes on the REI website. You can also find Bontrager shoes that take the Delta Look cleats on Trekbikes.com. I found cycling shoes on Zappos, too.

Bontrager Velocis Road cycling shoes

And the verdict? I bought these Bontrager Velocis Road cycling shoes. They come in a wide width like my original pair of Bontrager bike shoes. However, only the black color came in wide otherwise I would have gotten the fancy blue ones shown below. They also come in red and in white.

They’re a dual cleat shoe, too. So, I could have put SPD cleats on them if I wanted. But, as you know, the Peloton cycle takes the triangle-shape cleat called a Delta cleat.

As soon as I get the Delta cleats attached, I’m taking them out for a spin! Finally, I bought these on TrekBikes.com.

Pro tip with TrekBikes.com: as soon as you click through to the online store, set up an account. Once you’ve regiestered with TrekBikes.com, you’ll get free shipping on all of your returns. Only those with a registered account qualify for this freebie. So, don’t delay.

Bontrager Cycling Shoes

Other cycling shoe alternatives include wide widths

If, for whatever reason, you decide not to buy your bike shoes on the Peloton website, you have plenty of other options. Back in 2016 I went to my local cycle store to get my Bontrager brand bike shoes. Like my husband I have wide feet. So they recommended I get a brand that would take the Look Delta clips and came in wide. I got the Bontrager brand.

bontrager peloton bike shoes
These are my Bontrager brand of Peloton bike shoes. You can buy them, for under $100, at REI.com.

FYI, in everyday shoes, I can wear anything from an 8WW to a 9W. Sometimes I’m an 8.5. In my bike shoes I got a size 42. In this brand that was the equivalents of a size 9. I’m not sure, though, if that was a men’s 9–which would match up with the Peloton shoe size guide above–or a woman’s 9. The label on the inside actually says “wide.”

Here, I’ve collected a variety of wide cycle shoes for Peloton. These are cycling shoes for wide feet that come in a wide width and will work with your Peloton bike. 

Best Peloton Shoes for Wide Feet

There are a couple of websites that sell cycling shoes for wide feet that you can use with your Peloton. The websites include Trekbikes.com, REI.com and Backcountry.com.

As far as the brands offering wide widths in shoes for the Peloton bike, these include Bontrager (which I wear), Sidi, Lake and Shimano. I've included links to some of these brands and website here.

FYI, since stores like REI have physical locations around the country, it's always possible to buy online and then use curbside pickup, if your shoes are in stock at your local store.

You can buy Bontrager brand of cycling shoes on the REI website. You can also find Bontrager shoes that take the Delta Look cleats on Trekbikes.com. Bontrager does not sell on Amazon.

Best Cycling Shoes for Peloton

Looking for the best cycling shoes for Peloton? Here are some highly rated options.

You can also find a small selection of cycling shoes on Zappos, especially for kids.

Peloton for Kids: Cycling Shoes and More

If you're wondering about kids Peloton shoes, I've offered a few options below. I've also include toe cage straps that you can attach to your pedals. This will allow your children to wear their regular shoes (sneakers, gym shoes, running shoes) while riding the bike.

Finally, if you’re aware of other online options for getting bike shoes that take the Look Delta cleats, please let me know.

Looking for wide width everyday shoes for women? Check out this review!

Shoe cages for Peloton

If you don’t want to spend money on special shoes for your Peloton, you don’t have to. But you should invest in shoe cages, also known as toe cages. These are straps that attach to your bike pedals. Then, you slip your regular gym shoes, running shoes or sneakers into the cages while you ride.

Because the Peloton pedals are fairly narrow and flat, cages are a good idea. There is a lot of “out of saddle” work you do during rides. That means you’ll be standing up. When I first tried riding the bike with my sneakers on and no cages, I kept falling. Let me tell you–those pedals will scrape your shins really well (sarcasm).

The shoe cages we got for our bike came with the Look Delta cleat attached to the bottom. That way you can clip in without have the special shoes or replacing the pedals. These toe cages have multiple holes in patterns on them. So, it looks like you could use them with SPD cleats, too.

In addition, I recently discovered that Rei.com sells shoes cages or toe straps. They call them toe clips with straps. From reading the reviews, it looks like these will work with a Peloton bike. 

Finally, you can find plenty of toe cage options for a Peloton bike on Amazon.

Toe Cages for Peloton Bike on Amazon

There may be a number of reasons you could be looking for toe cages (or shoe cages) for your Peloton bike.

It could be that you don't want to use cycling shoes with Delta Look cleats--the kinds that are compatible with Peloton cleats. Perhaps you have SPD cleats on existing shoes and want pedals that can take those cleats and have cages, too.

Or you may have multiple people using the Peloton bike, not all of whom wearing cycling shoes with cleats.

Or you have guest riders from time to time who want to wear sneakers or tennis shoes when riding.

These are all valid reasons to invest in toe cages, which usually come attached to a pedal that you can screw right into the crank shaft on the Peloton bike. All of the options below are available, conveniently, on Amazon.

Best shoes for Peloton bike

You want to make sure that your shoes come with the Delta cleats. Those are red triangles cleats that attach to the bottom of your shoe and work with the Peloton pedals. Your Peloton compatible shoes should have three holes on the bottom to take the Delta clips. These are also known as Look Delta cleats and are the Peloton cleats type.

These Tomasso shoes, for example, list that they are compatible with Peloton bike pedals. It’s important to look for Peloton compatible shoes. How do you determine if the cycling shoes you’re considering are Peloton compatible shoes and therefore the best cycling shoes for Peloton? You want to look for which cleats those shoes use.

Again, here is my new review on the best Peloton bike shoes.

Peloton bike shoes on Amazon

I’ve put together an exclusive shopping list on Amazon. It includes almost a dozen different kinds of Peloton-compatible bike shoes.

How are they compatible if they’re not the Peloton brand? Because they have the LOOK Delta triangle-shape cleats on the bottom.

I’ve highlighted some of them below.

Peloton Bike Shoes Amazon

You can find a number of different brands of bike shoes on Amazon, all compatible with Peloton, because they take the Look Delta cleat.

Peloton bike cleats

Peloton compatible shoes use Look Delta cleats. To know that you have the right shoe for Peloton bike cleats, look for three holes on the bottom of the shoe. This is where you’ll attach the cleat. FYI, Peloton bike cleats are also sometimes called clips. So if you read about Peloton shoe clips or Peloton clips, that’s likely what the writer meant.

If you took spin classes at your gym, chances are you make have used a spin bike that took shoes with two holes on the bottom. These cycling shoes use a cleat called SPD. You do not want these as your Peloton spin shoes. If you already own these, unfortunately you’re going to have to buy new Peloton bike shoes. Or you can switch the pedals.

Bike shoe accessories

Regardless of what kind of bike shoes you get, you might be interested in some Peloton bike shoe accessories. When I say accessories, I mean products that can help make storing your shoes (and other equipment) easier and neater.

Shoe Storage

I get a lot of questions about shoe storage options. For starters, if there is just one of your riding, it’s easy. You can hang your shoes off the weight rack on the back of the bike. 

But what if you’re like my family, with multiple people riding, all wearing different shoes? Then you’re going to have to invest in a shoe hanger.

I know that a shoe hanger is pretty popular. You can find these on Etsy. These shoe hangers, which look like big hooks, go on the back of your bike. They hang off under the weight rack. These allow you to hang more than one pair of shoes up to dry.

Best Peloton Accessories: Shoe Hanger

Here are inexpensive yet effective shoe hangers you can buy on Etsy.

Another shoe accessory is a wall shelf. I’ve seen them, also on Etsy, made of wood and big enough to hold a ton of stuff, like shoes and towels. So this is another option for a Peloton shoe holder or storage for your shoes.

I just discovered this third option for storing shoes. It is a set of double-sided metal hooks, if you will, that fits onto the weight holders on the back of the bike. From there you can hang two pairs of shoes. I just installed this shoe rack on my bike, and you can buy them on Amazon.

Peloton Bike Shoes Storage

Here is a picture of my ATP Sports shoe rack with my husband and my shoes on it, just so you can see how it works in real life.

double peloton shoe rack from side long view

Best socks to wear with bike shoes

Finding the best socks to wear with your Peloton bike shoes is a little like Goldilocks. You don’t want socks that are too thin or too thick or that run big or small. You want socks that are just right.

In all my years of riding my bike, I’ve found that Bombas socks are the “just right” socks for spinning. They’re comfortable, padded where they need to be and wick away moisture–if you have sweaty feet like I do.

There are a number of different styles of Bombas sock to choose from. If you decide to take my advice and invest in Bombas socks, let me offer this one piece of advice. Go for the quarter height or performance cycling socks.

I made the mistake of getting the no-show kind. They’re super cute when I wear them for everyday. But I find that they sit too low inside my cycling shoes so the shoes end up rubbing my ankles.

Finally, another benefit to Bombas socks? They’re guaranteed for life. 

Here’s my article on other products guaranteed for life.

I’ve highlighted a few of my favorites below. Bombas makes socks for men and women.

Bombas Products Guaranteed for Life

Best Peloton shoes

So what are the best cycling shoes for Peloton? Clearly, the best shoes for your Peloton bike are the ones that fit your feet comfortably and your budget, too. If you find that the pricing on the Peloton website is the best around, then get those shoes. As I’ve mentioned, even my husband with wide, hard-to-fit feet found that the Peloton brand shoes worked for him.

In conclusion, are the Peloton shoes good? Are the Peloton shoes worth it? Well, my husband has been using them since 2016 and they still look almost new. Same with me and my Bontrager shoes. I’ve worn them every time I ride, and I ride daily. They, too, are in great condition.

peloton workout plan pdf
I hope you’ll check out my new Peloton workout planner on Etsy.

Overall thoughts on Peloton bike shoes

I’m sure you can find cycling shoes priced cheaper than $125 on the Peloton website. However, remember that sometimes you get what you pay for.

I know that my cycling shoes for Peloton cost about $100. Like the Peloton cycle shoes, they’ve lasted since 2016. If you cheap out and get crappy bike shoes, you could end up paying double in the long run. Double when the shoes hurt your feet or you have to buy new shoes.

In addition, at some point, you should be able to visit a nearby cycle shop. There you can have a professional fit you for your bike shoes. Also, you will be supporting a local business.

Finally–and this bears repeating–when buying Peloton spin shoes, you want the kind with three holes on the bottom. These take the Look Delta clips, which are the kind of pedals that come with your bike. It doesn’t matter what brand you buy–they must have three holes in the bottom. I know some people switch out their pedals to take the SPD cleat shoes that they use with their outdoor bikes. If that works for you, then go for it.

26 thoughts on “Peloton Bike Shoes Review”

  1. Hi Leah! I sure wish I would have found you a year ago. I just started following you this morning after searching for bike seat covers. Thank you for the SoKomfy discount! My tailbone is JACKED and I look forward to trying it out (currently typing while sitting on a gel ice pack). We would love the shelf. Our workout room is an extension of our living space. We have several riders at our house and plenty of shoes. I would love to be able to display this beauty and keep everything organized. My daughter and I just received a Paint Party in a Box to paint two flower pot cactus gardens for our workout space and this would be the perfect spot to display them as well. Thanks again for your helpful posts. It’s invaluable to have such thoughtful input before making a decision to purchase something. Happy riding!

    Reply
  2. Awesome post and drawing, I’d love this shelf! I’m awaiting my Peloton bike and have found your posts so helpful in figuring out what to anticipate and how to get the most out of my bike. I’m not sure where I’ll put my shoes yet, but this shelf would be perfect!

    Reply
  3. Love to win the peloton shoe rack for our second bedroom. We have only just purchased our peloton and the shoes are still in the box but they’d have a lovely home to go to if we won this amazing rack 😍 Also just like to say how helpful your blogs have been before we’ve even got on the bike I’ve been reading through all your tips for beginners and it’s been a huge help!! Thank you x

    Reply
  4. We currently store our shoes on the mat next to the bike. I didn’t even think about other options but our walls are bare in the workout room so I need to start looking at all of the options. I love the wall mount.

    Reply
  5. What an informative post! I am so happy to have found you Leah and just started following you on Instagram! I am waiting for delivery of my Peloton and have my workout space ready for her! Wasn’t sure what I would do with the shoes and that rack is perfect! Thanks again for all the info! Love your Blog!

    Reply
  6. I had no idea about how often to change spin shoes! This really got me thinking! The shelf would be a great addition to our (future) spin room as we are looking to buy our first home and move in the coming months! Would love to have a functional space rather than just place our shoes on the box they come in on our nearest bookshelf (in the corner of our living room!) Thanks for all the info!

    Reply
  7. Thank you for this competition! I’m currently laying my shoes down right by my Peloton (sat next to my indoor plant!). A shelf would be PERFECT! I’ve been eyeing up the shelf on Etsy as I’m a sucker for organising all of my fitness stuff in one place. It would be great to keep my sweat towels and hairbands all in one place – to avoid my running around the flat with my cleats on to get everything together, 5 mins before a live ride!

    Reply
  8. I have a newer pair of Torch 3.0 and my hubby just bought a new pair for himself TODAY!! Currently we have no good storage for our shoes and I LOVE this shelf!! So cool and what a brilliant idea!!!
    This shelf would be so handy for us because we would have a neat space to organize our towels and shoes because we are so proud of our Peloton Biking and our Peloton space. It would be the perfect addition!!!!

    Reply
  9. I currently just lay my shoes down next to my peloton – the shelf on the wall would be PERFECT! It is adorable and so functional! It would also help me so I don’t forget a towel — I’m notorious for that!

    Reply
  10. Thanks for doing this Leah!! I have been eyeing up that shelf on Etsy as we have a mess on our hands with 2 pairs of shoes and wipes and bands…the list goes on. We have our gym in the garage and there is a ledge we use for ALL the things. It would be so nice to have a shelf to keep things organized and cute at the same time!!

    Reply
  11. Really need a shoe rack for our Peloton bike shoes. we’re currently placing them on a nearby bookshelf to keep them off the floor so our dogs don’t chew them…

    Reply

Leave a Comment